Skip to content
REVV NETWORK TV
Bafana Bafana News

Pitso Mosimane Defends His Selection After Bafana’s Draw, But Fans Want Answers

Bafana Bafana’s disappointing 2-2 draw against Kenya has opened a debate that goes beyond the two points dropped. Head coach Pitso Mosimane is facing questions over his selection decisions, particularly his decision to leave Mbekezeli Mbokazi and Thalente Mbatha out of the starting line-up.

The frustration among supporters is understandable. Bafana twice took the lead but failed to protect their advantage, eventually conceding a late equaliser after a defensive mistake.

For many fans, Mbokazi’s absence was one of the biggest talking points. The Chicago Fire defender had returned to the squad, but Mosimane opted to continue with Ime Okon and Olwethu Makhanya in central defence.

Mbatha also had to wait for his opportunity, with Teboho Mokoena and Sphephelo Sithole starting in midfield.

Pitso stands by his selection

Mosimane had already explained his thinking before the match. He wanted to maintain the momentum created by players who had performed well during the previous fixtures rather than automatically restore returning players to the starting eleven.

His message was that nobody should expect an automatic place after returning from injury. Players who stepped in during their absence also deserved recognition.

After the draw, however, the coach was confronted with questions about Mbokazi’s omission.

He was visibly unhappy when a journalist suggested that starting the defender could have helped Bafana avoid dropping points.

“Now you choose who must play? We lost because of that or we lost because we missed many chances?” Mosimane asked.

He argued that Bafana created enough opportunities to win the match but failed to take them. In his view, possession and attractive football mean very little if a team cannot convert its chances.

It is a reasonable argument, considering the opportunities South Africa wasted. But it does not completely answer the questions about the defensive decisions.

Is the Sundowns favouritism accusation fair?

Another discussion gaining momentum among supporters is the suggestion that Mosimane is showing favouritism towards players from Mamelodi Sundowns.

There is currently no established evidence that club affiliation influenced his selection. However, the criticism reflects a wider concern about whether players are being judged by the same standards, regardless of which club they represent.

A national team should reward performance, form and suitability for the match. Previous contributions and reputations should not guarantee anyone a starting place.

But the same principle must apply to players who have performed well enough to earn opportunities. If a player comes into the team during an injury absence and does his job, he should also be given a fair opportunity to retain his position.

That is where the debate becomes interesting.

The next match will tell us more

Mosimane has defended his decisions, but the result against Kenya has given supporters more reason to question his selection policy.

The coach is right that missed chances contributed to the dropped points. Equally, defensive mistakes and the players selected to deal with those situations deserve scrutiny.

The discussion should not simply become a battle between Orlando Pirates and Mamelodi Sundowns supporters. The bigger issue is whether Bafana are selecting players based on what they bring to the national team.

With the return fixture against Kenya coming up in Nairobi, Mosimane has an immediate opportunity to respond.

For now, one question remains: if players are only as good as their last game, how long does it take for a returning player to earn his place back?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *